I see both sides of this argument. In my commentary, I did say "it doesn't immediately jump out at me" and thus I see the point being made by...
And it's MS 62 ...the grading on these is sometimes hard to nail down. I think 62 is a bit harsh and would agree with the 63 crowd. [ATTACH]
MS 66
A great looking Buffalo in a cool holder! :)
Reveal coming soon....
That is the most common date for it but the variety exists on plenty of other Franklins. http://www.franklinlover.yolasite.com/bugs-bunny.php
65 ...luster looks to be booming and the fields are super clean...Peace Dollars seems to take a bit more to get up to a 66 though (vs Morgans), so...
My guess/vote is MS 66 as it looks fairly clean and mark-free (but I could see a 65 if an older holder). Based on what I'm seeing the last few...
I went with MS 65 not FBL ...the luster is probably there but the black patch on the obverse and a few scattered hits prevent me from going higher...
I'm not sure. On one hand, I like the look better as-is vs. what I imagine it would look like dipped. On the other hand, if dipped properly, it...
I recall you had a group of coins where some looked closer to AT but others looked closer to MA (based on comparable ones being graded) where I...
@Lehigh96 I do see what you mean about the reverse of the toned example. The obverse on that one is much better. Why not list both coins for sale...
Weak strike, minimal hits, nice color = MS 65 for me
That's not on the poll :eek::p:D
Please guess the grade and use the poll. :) [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
MS 64 ....I don't see any significant hits but the color seems deep enough to potentially limit the luster, thus I went a step below gem.
I like it but it doesn't immediately jump out at me (I feel this way about many Buffalo and Jefferson nickels). So my score is 4.0
I'll take door #2 based on liking the color. I think the grades are within 1 point of each other with #1 being higher (66 and 65). The two longer...
Floor is open...
No worries! I used the poll and posted.
Separate names with a comma.
