I grade you MS 70! :D Nice set; it's always fun to fill an album.
They will grade coins as PF 58 or even PF 10. As far as details coins, they will say "PR Genuine XF details" if it has worn down to XF and has a...
For everyone following this thread, the coin arrived and it's not as bad as the NGC cert photo shows. There is some light hazing but at most...
I hear you and agree that "market acceptable" can be a problematic term. In this case, I was using it instead of natural toning because I can't...
The rim would bother me enough to not sticker it but it seems like JA thought it was acceptable.
I don't think NGC was close here (well besides the UNC part, that was right). The toning looks like it would come from either being in a leather...
Luckily I bought it already in the NGC holder, so I didn't spend any money on the NGC grading fees (it stinks for the person who originally sent...
Part 3 is now posted here: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/pcgs-sub-has-arrived-guess-the-grade-part-3-of-5.385091/
We continue along in my PCGS sub. This is part 3 of 5. Please guess the original grade and the new grade (originally NGC and now PCGS). Are they...
We had some people come close but this was a tricky one. NGC originally called this Unc Details - Artificial Toning (which I disagreed with-the...
Here is a video of the coin I just posted: https://www.instagram.com/p/CSsYlRKLb1z/
That's what I thought too. No luck on this particular coins (I'd argue they were actually quite conservative given the color).
Somehow I missed this thread :banghead: My grade guesses before the reveal were: AU 55 ...something about it made me think circulated MS 65...
That's true. The best case scenario would be select videos (maybe a few dealer tables that allowed it and some of the displays).
There was a guy there that was recording a video of the Tyrant collection for his YouTube channel (I could tell as he was narrating as he was...
I'll extend this one (possibly until tomorrow). @Morgandude11 @jtlee321 and others still need to guess too.
That's fair! You got this one right and might as well call it a day (I know I've done that before :D).
I don't know. :p I can be a tricky fellow when it comes to Guess the Grade threads. :D
Part 2 has been posted here: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/pcgs-sub-has-arrived-guess-the-grade-part-2-of-5.385010/
I agree. Of the five coins I sent in, this was the one I was most confident in! So much for that confidence. :eek::p
Separate names with a comma.
