The risk is if it were to get a cleaned designation from pcgs, I lose the option of returning it to the QC designation. Oh well (fingers crossed)...
Update- decided to give the coin 1 more shot with pcgs. If it gets a straight grade or a details grade-it's going to auction....
Was bidding on 8 different 1971 topps baseball cards-mostly$3-10 range. I lost the first seven but had the high bid on the eighth. I'm thinking...
According to Heritage, they still have the old pcgs-qc slab and can claim ignorance of knowing how it "broke".
Thanks Paul- I think I'm leaning that way too.
Update: cracked out the coin and submitted to NGC, came back "improperly cleaned." Now I'm not sure which way to go. My consignment director says...
My faith in pcgs gets lower every day
Rockin' good news! HA has agreed with us and thinks we should crack and re-submit the coin! Praying for a good outcome...
Heritage says they are going to get together and give me their opinion on possible re-submission. Waiting to hear back from them...
Just fired off an e-mail to my consignment director at heritage asking about the possibility of a re-grade. I thank you all for your opinions. I'm...
Yeah, it was submitted by heritage. Looks the same as it did when we cracked it out of the capital holder. Total of 62 cents were submitted, 50...
More info- the coin was in a capital plastics holder for at least 45 years-consigned with heritage- and returned with this grade...
Hi all- Interested in some opinions on this coin/ grade[ATTACH] [ATTACH] . What do you see that makes it look QC?
Thanks Bill- I have no experience submitting to anacs, and I appreciate your insight. I think I am leaning toward submitting the top 20 to pcgs...
good idea Tommyc- I think I'll take them to the long beach show and see what I can do. Isn't pcgs having some kind of pre long beach submission...
Excellent ideas all- I do appreciate your perspectives. I had heard of the bulk submission option but it looks like that is no longer an option...
The 1 representative coin I submitted came back as a 66. To my amateur eye, they all appear to be that nice. There are two coins with slightly...
I have 3 rolls (60 coins) of BU walking liberty halves, 2 rolls of 1944, and 1 roll of 1942. I have submitted 1 coin to pcgs which came back as an...
Obverse is very boring with some bagginess and a wee bit of toning on 1 edge- reverse is way cool.
Hopefully improved photo...[ATTACH] [ATTACH]
Separate names with a comma.
