I didn't say you said they were all under-graded. But you did say, in part "... but I tell you others are 64's, and that is a fact." That sounds...
You ARE crazy if you think you can state, as fact, that they are under-graded. I guess you haven't seen enough real life examples of how wonderful...
I read several replies (the first page) and then noticed this is a long thread. So, before I read the rest of it... My guess is that the coin...
My concern is the leg on the 1917, which I'm guessing has hits and or luster breaks over a good portion of it. And if it looks like I suspect it...
I tried to explain it already. It's a matter of having some combination of the right coins, the right relationship and the right knowledge with...
To me, the leg on the 1928-S looks better than on the 1917. And I don't think it's a harsh point at all, as in large part, that leg often...
I've seen very mixed results for the coins I've reported to Ebay, both before and after the article was published. And believe me, it's a large...
See my comments a few posts up as to why the coin looks accurately graded, as opposed to under-graded.
I don't think anything is up. My grade guess, before I scrolled down to view the assigned grade, was MS64FH, and I didn't need to see the reverse...
It's not always the case, but frequently, the large submitters are more expert and skilled at grading. That, plus the sheer numbers of coins they...
That can be a dangerous conclusion to (try to) arrive it based on an image.
I wasn't implying that this particular seller could get better than a 5% seller's fee rate, as I have no idea what would be included in a...
Depending upon 1) the value and desirability of the consignment; 2) the knowledge level and negotiating skills of the consignor and 3) the...
The surfaces of a Proof coin could be said to be more fragile than those of a business strike, due to their propensity to acquire hairlines from...
I'll answer your questions, even though you didn't answer mine.:) In the absence of mitigating circumstances/particulars, I think it is...
I saw a coin on Ebay today that appears similar to a number which have sold in the $2000 price range recently. Yet the PCGS Price Guide price is...
I was very surprised to see the listing shut down and have no idea what the basis was. One last hypothetical for you (for now) and then I'll let...
Without belaboring the point, based on the auction records I viewed, it appears that PCGS MS65FH 1928-S Quarters have been selling for roughly 30%...
You're entitled to your opinion, but many of them do not. Strike is only one component of a coin's grade. And if a coin is otherwise essentially...
Business strike coins aren't made to look like Proofs through ionization. Were you trying to be funny? Or do you just not understand what might,...
Separate names with a comma.
