Even if you didn't ask what others think about the listing, when you start a thread that includes "Fake Alert!" in the title, if readers think you...
And I'll ask again, who (if anyone) told you it was counterfeit? It looks genuine to me.
I think the second coin linked looks like an obvious counterfeit and nothing like the first one.
I was asking if you had images of the one you had already bought, which you said you had been told was counterfeit and which supposedly matched...
I must admit, looking at that listing, I wouldn't have thought that coin was a counterfeit. Who told you it was?
Can you post images of it? The one in the listing looks genuine to me, though I'm guessing the color is off due to a white balance issue in the...
The linked coin looks genuine to me - what am I missing?
There' s a big difference between knowing how to grade properly and doing so when selling. The seller might be an excellent grader.
You seem to start out with a sweeping, overly broad statement, get called on it and then clarify or change what you are saying. Why not start out...
If it's dated 1902 and smaller than a dime, as the poster indicated, it's not a U.S. gold coin.
That (Lehigh96's post) is my understanding, as well.
It looks nothing like a Proof to me. It doesn't have the strike/detail, surfaces, or squared edges of a Proof. I also think the color looks unnatural.
See the post by Lehigh96, above your previous one.
It doesn't matter to me if you tested certain coins or not. That doesn't change the fact that there are a multitude of ways that coins are AT'd...
I do that too, sometimes.:o
I agree, but there was nothing written about the original poster's friend to indicate that was what he was doing.
I don't know who you're speaking of, but I promise, I wasn't trying to cause problems.
My return comment was meant for the original poster. He provided no details, so I was guessing that he had discovered he had paid too much for...
Are you asserting that the above coin looks so similar to the one at the beginning of this thread, that NGC has "no coinsistency"? If so, that...
Merely that a poster named "rockdude", replied to a thread in which the person who started it referred to his friend as a "rockhead". I would have...
Separate names with a comma.
