Correct, he is.
He has answered this question in this forum on another thread, yes he does check all the coins before overstriking.
I see many articles which ask how can we bring new collectors into the hobby, Carrs pieces may well do that. Many senior collectors frown upon...
I try both, reporting to eBay seems to do nothing, politely educating the seller occasionally works. More often than not the seller will argue or...
The argument to protect the hobby may well end up hurting the hobby. It seems it has no teeth to stop eBay listings or the Chinese from scamming,...
Safe space trigger warning issued lol. I can see both sides of this. I do see your protection angle. Often what new people collect is not what...
You are correct. But those collectors who like his work would suffer, so the hobby would also suffer in a small way.
I can even remember How about if he changes his name to 'Liberty'? Lol
I doubt that. Out of the thousands of coins I have eaten crow maybe three or four times. Each time it has been a very tasty lesson, well worth the...
I meant honesty from the buyer lol. Many times it is the idea of getting a 'bargain' that drive a seller to make a mistake, which is greed. other...
You are interpreting the law, which is your opinion and you may be correct. However for those purchasing from Mr Carr at this time it seems to be...
Many times I have seen a coin with great eye appeal and luster. However I do not know the series and have passed due to my lack of knowledge. The...
And a third, honesty.
You seem to be using emotional arguments rather than logical ones, which is why I say you seem emotional. Even today as an 'experienced'...
If others have begun to produce fantasy coins which are not fantasy coins or overstrikes, how can they parrot his argument? Their argument must be...
No worse than many who come on here daily and ask questions. They find a quarter in change with damage and believe they have found a rare,...
So then what is the point of arguing as you do here? If the pieces are legal to own, you are arguing law which has nothing to do with owning them,...
Your argument is absurd, how is anyone going to be cheated? Seems to me that you just don't like Mr Carr personally for whatever reason. Which is...
As an owner of a single Carr piece (the regular Morgan) and now considering the prooflike Morgan, my main concern is whether it is legal to own...
"As a matter of statutory interpretation, I think that argument fails." This seems to be the central point? I do not doubt your opinion or thoughts.
Separate names with a comma.
