And it is very rare that you will ever see me argue when I miss on a grade guess based on a photo :D
You have me wrong , I know that Au Bust Halves can be graded as MS . I already posted that in an indirect way when I said that I thought some...
I thought the surface of the coin was a bit marked up for better then a MS 62 .
I would grade this MS 61 maybe 62 . I could see why people might give it Au 58 . What is the grade on this coin ?
I thought it would be at least a MS 64 . How can you use a MS 65 coin to compare with a MS 62 coin ? Someone with your level of expertise should...
GDJ- please answer my question . What is the grade of the coin you used and is it raw or slabbed?
Leigh , I can not answer why it only received an MS 62. That is splitting hairs for me. As for the Au 58 –VS MS 63 comment. That is very typical...
Lead - the coin is in my safe deposit box . The reason I posted the two pictures was because the PCGS picture showed the luster better then my...
And the coin in your example is graded MS – 62 , 63, 64, 65 ?? Is this coin raw or in a slab . ?? Posting that coin and not giving a grade does...
The responses were about what I though would be posted. Au 58 or MS 63 is what I would have guessed on this coin based on a photo. The difference...
Lets forget about the Luster, there is plenty under that light brown tone and focus on where you see wear. I will assume you are familiar with...
Overton 109 .
I think I have figured it out . Take the grade on the slab and subtract 5 – 6 grades to come up with the grade GDJMSP will assign. :rolleyes::D
Gee Leigh you did not have to apologize to me .:smile I understand your point on the matter now as you have clarified it for me. Nothing wrong...
GDJ and Se I wont post the grade right now but why would you grade this Bust AU 50 ?
All things created equal , I will take the opinion of John Albanese over pretty much anyone. I wonder if this thread is going to morph into a...
CAC is tough on gold. Out of the 15 or so gold Indians I have sent to CAC only 5 were certified. Some of the coins that were rejected were...
Seeing that my last guess the grade post received some controversy I thought I would put a small twist on this one . The top picture is from...
I understand where you are coming from . I know you realize that grading from a photo is at best a guess. Until they can make photos 3D so we can...
Ok so what you are saying and I want to make sure I am really clear on this . Based on a photo, you think someone can grade better then a TPG...
Separate names with a comma.
