I have been collecting coins for 40 years. During that time I took a break of 20 years from 1988 up until 2 years ago when I started to collect...
I sent the FH dollar to PCGS last October of 2009. I had sent it to NGC first. The Bust Half was originally graded AU 55 by ANACS. I sent it to...
The FH dollar was graded VF 30 by ICG when I bought it for VF 15-20 money . I sent it to NGC with a minimum grade for a cross at VF 20 , They...
I am done with the arguing . SE if I insulted you I apologize, it was not really my intention. GDP please grade those coins I posted.
I agree !!
This coin is obviously thumbed !!
O geez I hurt your feelings. Thank you for showing all of us your true colors. If I stuck the coins up my A-- would that adversely affect the...
SE drop it already – because this can turn really ugly and nasty. I have better things to do then convince you that I am far from being Naïve....
Leigh, I think SE was trying to bait me as well. I don’t want this to turn ugly so lets see some grade guesses on the other two coins I posted....
No Duke I will not send you the coin :D
I set the trap and you took the bait. You are very argumentative, I already knew that . I am not naïve, rather far from it. You calling me naive...
So that is your reason ?? Because it looks like it was ? I don’t have to defend why I don’t think it thumbed and that your comment was ridiculous...
Actually you are the one who needs to explain why , you tell me why you think it was thumbed ?
The strainer is still intact . I never doubted his ability to grade , I argued that he should not dispute a grade from PCGS and CAC based on a...
You sure seem like you think that you are an authority on grading . With that said you have proven to me that you should be considered an...
I agree with the grade on the NGC coin at Au 50 . Strongly disagree with the Au 50 on the PCGS coin although with the larger Heritage picture I...
Add another vote from me for the NGC forum.
Top coin – this is a late die state , mushy strike. Based only on the photo I would give it Au 58 tops. The coin also looks to have been dipped....
Ahh but do you study the real ones or just the photos :rolleyes:
Based on what I have seen, Leadfoot has an excellent grasp on grading .
Separate names with a comma.
