I had to read thru the post a few times and I'm still not sure what's going on. It appears he's a roll hunter and has had some luck. I like the...
I never got got into the special labels on slabs. I know I've seen slabs being with X signature on them but, didn't realize how it was done. So...
Wrong mint. The D mint isn't as obvious.
Not surprised at the grade. I had as MS 63 but possibly a 64. I put it as PL and not DMPL because picture can be misleading. The grade seems...
The gouge would kill it for me. I agree with johnmilton's MS 61 or 62. Even without the gouge MS 63 max.
I'm going with 63 PL possible DMPL but, hard to tell with the pictures. Seems to be to many hits to be much better than a 63 but, wouldn't be...
looks Neat! I'd keep it.
OK, I've done the same thing in the past. Bought on a whim then. Better than if you said hoping to make a profit. Back in 2006 to 2008 I bought...
Nice for $20.00.
Environmental damage.
My first question would be, why did you buy them?
This is my 1864 dollar.[ATTACH]
This is my 1846 dollar.[ATTACH]
1863 Dollar proof 62.[ATTACH] [ATTACH]
I agree with MS 62. Typical weak strike.
Over grading keys has been going on for a long time. A few years ago I saw a lot of 1877 Indian cents graded good to good 6 that were really...
I can't see where you think it may be cleaned. The coin has to much crud on it to give me the impression of being cleaned. I think the lighting...
Your right this is a details coin. I have seem coins in detail slabs that I had a hard time finding out why.
There will be some demand for the type two's but, it will drop fast. However, I think the mintages will also be low because of the cost of...
I'd go with almost EX Fine because 1908-S tend to have weaker strikes.
Separate names with a comma.
