just for clarification, yes, I submitted it in the holder....no crack-out
you, my friend, have the right idea I tried it b/c I thought the coin was so OBVIOUSLY ok, that it would cross, at any grade. Morgans with wacky...
PCGS has their guidelines for what's ok toning-wise, NGC has their standards, etc It's absurdly arbitrary, and there is NO definition of...
I promise, the link is straight to the GC auction
[IMG]
1898-O, originally graded MS64 in old green holder (the real one)....sent to PCGS thru GC, did not cross, ended up in Details holder:...
^this is what I meant the toning all over the face makes it hard to see the luster, but I assume in hand the coin glows
I guess CAC didn't like it when it became a 68 lol....I assume the weak breast feathers are the reason I applaud the consigner, I wish it...
MOON MONEY last night $15,936: https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/676306/1883-O-Morgan-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS-66-CAC-Toned [ATTACH]
[ATTACH]
Jackie's ok: [IMG]
here's an example of a coin currently at GC that I would've definitely consigned to Legend instead:...
the deepest pockets for toners go to Legend for sure if the GC coin was sold at Legend, it would've used the TrueView style pics and had a couple...
the GC one has quite a bit of chatter along the hand/hip/skirt area, esp. compared to the Legend one which is pretty close to flawless IMO
I was just looking at it from the angle that a green-beaned rattler makes most buyers assume that the coin in the holder is 'maxed-out'...
not my coin, but wow at the difference: from MS65 to MS67+ CAC $1068 > $9900! first sold in a Rattler on March 25, 2018:...
xf/au $128 shipped [ATTACH] [ATTACH] [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
ddddd nailed it: [ATTACH] [ATTACH]
yeah, the colors are a bit mottled and variegated, it isn't gorgeous, but I'd hardly consider it 'hideous' it's not a Sunnywood toner, but for a...
sorry about the pic, I don't have the coin in hand... ….and so far, no one has picked the grade yet
Separate names with a comma.
