Except that I made a speculation, not a statement of fact. And it is based on years of experience with PCGS world coins. When I see a world coin...
Yes, you perfectly articulated my feelings on this, with a brilliant explanation. Their grades match my own because they aren't inflated like US...
I've seen many MS60-63 PCGS world coins that I knew would not cross to NGC as better than AU, and others straight graded in PCGS slabs that would...
You lose the postage cost both ways. For a $25 coin it isn't even remotely worthwhile to return for this reason alone. However, if you need...
Thanks to those who participated. Looks like NGC is the clear winner with more than 75% of the vote. [ATTACH]
A smaller dealer may be there 1-2 days. Perhaps Saturday morning and flying or driving out that day. They are frequently sharing a table with...
Definitely go for it. Not many AUs out there. This coin likely has better eye appeal than many of equivalent grade, plus it's the obverse that...
It's lovely. Considering the adjustment marks, the damage isn't very distracting. Overall it has great eye appeal. I would think low XF money for...
Something not mentioned yet, if the coin the dealer has is outside of his specialty, he may very well want to trade it for an equal value coin...
If it's something you love, go for it. I've given up a couple collections over the years to pursue other coins, and I haven't regretted the...
You know I'm a PCGS member as well as NGC, right? I don't by any means dislike PCGS. I use them for most US coins, and I think their service for...
You didnt answer my question. Also, this site has advanced collectors and industry experts from all over the world. Sure, we're missing the vast...
Your argument seems to be both that my opinion is unduly influential to the people on the site, and also that the opinions of the collectors on...
I am. Hence the poll. Seems the vast majority agree that NGC is the best for world coins.
Yes, but their grades are consistent. Any TPG needs some babysitting. NGC customer service makes it easier.
The premium is because I would be submitting the coin to NGC anyway. So I don't have to pay the grading fees if it's already slabbed. Plus there's...
I agree with these points wholeheartedly. I would also add that if you care about the competitive registry for world coins, NGC is also very...
I buy a lot of world coins and at strong bids, and while the lion share is raw, for slabbed, I discount PCGS coins because most are overgraded by...
I routinely pay with sacs/presidential dollars, SBAs, Kennedy halves, Ikes, and $2s. Most people are either excited or indifferent. One time I had...
I just picked the more well known/reputable graders. It's a poll so why not?
Separate names with a comma.
