The holder is cool. I'd leave it in that unless you want to sell it.
Like the circulated cameo look. Nice unified appearance!
Agree with 66 Great luster, no wear, no significant marks. What a beautiful coin! Just a great design - one of my favorites.
I'll go 64
The designs on so many of these classic commems are really cool.
Nice luster! I'll say 64
Nice coins. Thanks for sharing!
I'll say 65+ Nice coin!
63
My approach, may or may not work for all: -Dont bother to negotiate on a coin that costs less than $10. Dealer has little room there anyway....
I used to live there and had the best luck at Capitol Bullion on Burnet. They are straight shooters.
Nice pickups! Thanks for the report.
I collected casually as a teen, mostly from circulation. Then put it in a box for 20 years. Came back to it with renewed interest and a bit more...
I could see 58 to 62. Love the die cracks. This is one of my favorite designs. The withdrawn face of the pilgrim...the waves on the ocean. Well...
Beautiful coins! I'm just getting into world silver a little and enjoy seeing these.
Came to the party late. Nice coin though. Cool design!
I agree with the grade ballparks others have said. I can speak to your question about the look of a gray patina versus bright luster. I prefer...
64
It looks off to me as well. If the pictures represent the coin in hand accurately, then I would suspect it has been messed with.
64.
Separate names with a comma.
