63
1840 AU 58 1864S AU 50
In numismatics, The rarity of a coin, token, etc. is based on the quantity available. The rarity alone does not define the value. Demand for...
64
MS 64
Before seeing the TPG grade, I was MS 61+/- due to scrape at chin and hit in front of eye for the obverse and MS 64 for reverse -net MS 62 or 63.
VF 25 possibly cleaned. Better call if it were in hand so to speak.
AU 50- nice coin. XF 45-too many dings and scratches, especially the significant scratch to the right of the date.
I am also not an expert, but I am in the AU 53 to 55 range based on photos.
Obverse VF20+, Reverse VF 25+. Net grade VF 25. Possibly cleaned, but some time ago. Nice toning and eye appear. Probably slabbed VF 35 or XF 40.
My initial EF 45 grade was well before the posted grade. I apparently graded it twice at the same grade.
EF 45
58. Very light wear at high points-cheek, etc. Very nice coin!
EF 40
In general agreement with halfcent1793 comments. The TPG services in effect set the commercial value of the coin for those buyers who are not...
VF20
VF30-VF35 range IMO. EF40 probably a stretch.
Separate names with a comma.