If the damage or discoloration is on the slab, I am at MS 63. If the discoloration and damage were on the slab, one would assume at least the...
+1
The relatively wide, deep damage at the reverse rim appears to possibly be a knife cut, which puts it in Details territory imho. Otherwise, it’s...
XF 45
I probably used the wrong word “see” as in observe at the beginning of the post. It should have been in a phrase which included “my opinion”....
I am AU 55, probably dipped based on photos...not at all unusual for a Bust Half in that grade. Very nice coin.
I see a dipped AU 53 (do not see cleaning hairlines from photos), however in hand opinion could be different. It would get Details cleaned from...
Having heard many stories similar to the rip-off dealer and the uninformed lady selling a loved-ones coins, I decided to label all my slabs and...
XF 45...excellent coin.
AU 58... wear on eagle’s breast, several relatively minor dings, a moderate hit at eagle’s breast. Very nice coin.
VF 35
F-12 or F-15 IMHO. It’s in that range of value $100 raw and $140+/- in TPG slab that getting it slabbed is a toss up. If you are thinking of...
Huge hit to the nose... should be bleeding..other chatter at cheek and neck. I am at MS 62. Edit: Just realized that I posted the guess twice,...
I am at MS 62, but the TPG is at 63. For the record I select MS 63 in poll.
MS 64...to much chatter on cheek-my opinion of grade. NGC grade MS 65 no star. For the record, I posted MS 65 in the poll.
I GTG before seeing the reveal. Since we are at an average of MS 64.5 and the TPG grade is MS 66, it would appear that seeing the coin in hand...
I am at 65. A few light blemishes on the neck and the hazy areas on both sides of the coin does not allow a better grade IMO. Overall, it’s a...
My opinion: Germany 1 Reichspfennig XF (extremely fine) Value about $1.20 France 5 Centimes F-VF (Fine to Very Fine) Value about $2.00 Austria 1...
The KM catalog information can be accessed thru NGC at no cost with an on line search in the following example from Mountain Man’s numista link...
This was my opinion pre-reveal. The additional photos definitely better define the luster. MS 66 FB is reasonable, but MS65FB is an under grade IMO.
Separate names with a comma.
