Going with my gut on this one. AU58 While I do find this as an attractive nickel, I do not believe this can be anything higher than a 63. To me...
65 5FS was my guess. I am at 66 5FS without that cheek hit. I think the obverse just barely reaches 65 but the reverse is carrying it and seems...
#1 - Green - solid gem in a rare holder #2 - Green - looks to be a beautiful 66 #3 - no sticker - looks to be a nice 65 tho #4 - Gold - I see...
Slab has to be counterfeit. The grade AU50 does not match the grade listed in the code. The code has the grade 53. It’s been reported. At the...
F15
The most recent pictures showing the die crack between R and T have me totally convinced. This is something I would roll the dice on. Nice work...
5.8 for me. I love the neons and these ones are nice. This one also seems to have some textile toning on the obverse which I am a fan of. I like...
A little too crusty for my liking. Hard to read the surfaces with the patina on this one. I’m sure the luster is great. Only thing catching my eye...
Nice! :cigar: I wonder if they netted the 65 due to the small rim ding. It looks every bit of a 66 in terms of eye appeal. I thought the steps...
I voted for #2. I think the surfaces are a bit cleaner particularly the fields and the Monticello. I think both are almost full steps and appear...
3.2 on the Buffalo.
5.9 for me!
I feel honored to receive grades as high as these. I had it at a 4.0 and I am humbled to see I was the lowest of the opinions. Thanks everybody....
This one is not on the price level of near any of the coins in this thread but I wanted opinions on what you think of the toning. I submitted this...
Surprised this got a 65. I agree with the star but believe this should be a 64*. That cheek is tore up. I’m sure it’s not as distracting in hand...
2.5 on the 25 cent. Can I get in line? I have one that would be fun. We need more copper in this thread.
I feel good about this one. Got the FBL and the fact it was owned by your brother. I guess I penalized it for the darker area at 3pm more than NGC...
I like the coin and it’s design more than the toning. The toning does give it that classic silver tarnished look which I think goes well with the...
This got derailed a bit. I was at a 4.2 on the Buffalo. Proof Jefferson I had at 4.9.
I am terrible at grading Franklins. I am a fan of the crusty original patina. It shows that it likely has not been messed with. I think it’s a...
Separate names with a comma.
