I fail to see this fraud and confusion in the secondary market, other than unusual circumstances. Coin world have also done several pieces which...
I agree, he seems to me to care about the hobby, is very knowledgeable and has much experience. I believe his arguments are sound. Even supposing...
The proven method is to observe the guidance given in these posts, you are looking for a flawless coin with a good strike. However, you also have...
So to summarize here at this juncture. There is division over whether Mr Carr's overstrikes are within the law. There is no case which is the same...
Well that kills a whole bunch of ideas.
The law says that the coin must be marked with the word 'copy' correct? Does it have to be stamped into the coin, or any other stipulations?
The host is not destroyed or obliterated, it is altered. I don't know what level or type of collector you are, but each coin has die markers which...
You mean horse trailer?
Because the Chinese fake is struck on a blank, it is not an overstrike. "Chinese fake" means it is a Chinese fake. I don't know where you read...
So going back to the point here, a 1964 D Morgan was never struck. I consider myself a novice on Morgan dollars, yet the Carr fantasy token is...
I don't believe any law can protect people from themselves. Suppose I pay $10,000,000 for an extremely rare 1909 silver eagle (Chinese fake)...
Assuming you are correct, many of the silver rounds out there are in violation of the HPA. If this is your argument then why are we not seeing...
Do we not already have consumer protection laws? Why do we need another one? If for example you market 9/11 coins or medals. I have a genuine 9/11...
So it would be number two then, to protect people from themselves? So it is actually nothing to do with protecting the hobby.
So, I have to ask the question, regardless of the arguments which are ongoing. The Hobby Protection Act was passed for what reason? 1. Was it to...
Lol mooning! doesn't the HPA protect us against mooning?
The more I see the HPA interpretations on here, the more I believe that it may well damage the hobby more than help it. The intent of the HPA...
Again, I can only answer for the Morgan dollar, the Morgan dollar design has significant differences to an actual Morgan dollar. As I stated...
This point was addressed in Post 558. The statement "to be used or in aid of the counterfeiting of any such coins of the United States" does not...
You are right, the topic is about his offerings, I can only speak for the Morgan as I own no other.
Separate names with a comma.
