It's not magnetic, but it looks like the steel. The photos attached show the steel 1943 penny on the top left, the one in question is the 1944...
I have a similar coin, color and all, except that it's a 1944. However, it's not steel. Could it be all zinc? There are no signs of copper.
I have a similar looking coin that looks just like yours, color and all, except that it's a 1944 but it's not steel. It doesn't look like copper...
Separate names with a comma.