Actually, I think both of them look really nice. I would say XF-45 weak strike for the bottom one, and VF-20 for the top.
One would be the 1872-S dime. I recently lost one on ebay by $5 (was annoyed at that), and found only ONE on heritage that had been sold in the...
I'd also say AU-55 or 58. Definitely a nice buy.
That's what I thought. It's too bright and has a LOT of sliding marks. OP, keep in mind that pictures can be betraying. The first pictures I took...
PF 63 is harsh, I'd put it at PF 64 Cam + also.
I thought around 63/64, myself.
I did not think it was polished, at least not blatantly. I agree with dipped though, and often photos can make it hard to see remaining luster....
The coin is much better than AU-55, but I can't tell AU/MS because the pictures are honestly not that great.
I totally agree. Especially since you can't do jack about it, since sellers can't leave negative feedback any more. The feedback system WAS abused...
I bought from Shawn Yancey once and was pretty satisfied. His prices on non-copper coins seem to be quite good. I felt I did about $200 better...
Ah, alright. I'm sure that would be a big deal with some of the most valuable varieties.
Oh sure, I'm guilty of mildly overgrading a few coins at first glance also, definitely. Most likely because of poor knowledge of the series. By...
I wouldn't buy from him. He, or whoever works for him, labeled a coin 'choice original XF' which was maybe VF 25 or VF 30, cleaned reverse. I...
I'd grade AU-50 because of the flattening on the ribbon on the reverse. If this coin is fairly weakly struck, it could be MS, there appears to be...
F for the buffalo, VF+ for the 1891. Nice reverse!
I can't really tell from the pictures if the left one is an S, it could be an altered mintmark though, so I suggest going to a dealer to...
VG-10, reverse is the better side.
I agree that the reverse is very nice, though. Obverse will unfortunately limit the grade. I have an 1899 morgan with an MS-65+++ reverse and a...
Yep... But I agree with hobo, cool to own.
Is there a scratch near the last A in america, and a minor dig between the top leaves on the wreath? Either way, seems like a reasonable price. It...
Separate names with a comma.
