Your OP Diocletian is beautiful and the photography is brilliant. If you own only one ancient coin, one as lovely as this is the one to have. Thank you for sharing it. Attached is one of my argentei, in this case, a Rome issue of Diocletian's co-Augustus, Maximianus (RIC 27b).
Have you seen @lordmarcovan 's Eclectic Box of 20 collection? His method is very original. He’s curator of an ever changing numismatic museum. https://www.cointalk.com/threads/lord-marcovans-eclectic-box-collection-as-of-july-28-2017.300444/
Eh, my personal taste disagrees. I can certainly appreciate nice coins in any condition and I completely understand your viewpoint, but if they don't have it "all there," they're not really for my permanent collection. I'd rather spend the amount that I have on the best coin or medal I can possibly find, but if I had an unlimited budget I would still buy equally top quality coins, just more of them. As it stands my collection is all MS67-69 with only one or two exceptions, and most of the coins are beautifully toned.
Thanks for the info, didn't know that about the central dot in the compass! Not sure why NGC didn't mention the flan crack either, but personally I actually like them, especially on mint state coins like this one. I know they're generally viewed negatively but I find that they give coins character.
@Deacon Ray - you flatter me, sir. Note, however, that the Eclectic Box of 20 is no longer a "Box of 20". It is merely the "Eclectic Box" now (without the "- of 20" suffix). It will fluctuate slightly in quantity from now on - and is presently around 25 pieces - but 20 is a minimum. @Rexford - that is a simply stunning argenteus, with toning characteristic of examples from the 1953 Sisak hoard. I expect that must surely be part of the provenance on your coin. I share your challenge of pursuing high quality on a modest budget. You work for Atlas? Wow. At least you're in a perfect place, numismatically. I work as a relatively low-ranking hotel clerk. Atlas is my favorite place to shop these days. You must get to see some amazing stuff. I sometimes browse the Atlas inventory just to "window shop", but four times now I've scraped up the funds to be a paying customer. I've usually dealt with Chris Baker. Is it true you're only 19, as your profile says? If so, consider me all the more impressed.
Ok guys, let's not kid ourselves. OP's coin is ok, but not that impressive. It's not like I'm sitting here and I just can't stop thinking about that coin, and it's not like I would give my right arm and leg just to hold that coin and call it mine...oh, whom am I kidding? I want it so bad! I'm practically green with envy. I need it, I want it! I'm cuckoo for that OP silver argenteus like Sonny the Cuckoo bird lusting after a bowl of Cocoa Puffs.
I can't imagine that that Diocletian argenteus didn't cost you an arm and a leg. I'm presently deciding to invest more in my collection and am looking at various solidi. Sure beats the heck out of late roman bronze, I tell you - though I just picked up an AE30 of Julian II with Securitas Reipub on the reverse - must be the best issue ever in terms of LRB.
Thank you! I also suspect it is from the Sisak hoard but don't have an exact provenance for it. I will dig a little deeper sometime. Yep, I work at Atlas and love it there (and yes, it's often difficult to keep my focus on my work instead of on the coins I'm working with! So many great pieces!) I see you've still got three out of four of your purchases from us in your box of 20ish I am indeed 19. I'll post most of my collection below in a couple of minutes.
First coin I ever sent to a TPG, so it has a special place for me. PCGS MS65 1938-D/D Buffalo: First foreign coin I ever bought. PCGS MS67 1727 German States Hamburg 16 Schillings: PCGS MS67 German Empire 1914-A Mark: PCGS MS68 German Empire 1914-A Mark: PCGS SP65 1858 German States Baden Medal Wielandt-Zeitz-289 PCGS SP66 (1900) Japan Medal - Marriage of Crown Prince Yoshihito PCGS MS68 1897 Peru 1/2 Dinero PCGS MS67+ 1933 Chile Peso PCGS MS67 1867 Brazil 200 Reis
PCGS MS67 (ca. 1750) German States Regensburg 1/32 Ducat. Die lines aren't really visible in hand, so appears much smoother and prooflike. PCGS MS67 1881 German States Bavaria Shooting Medal - Peltzer 1472; Hauser 556; Steul 1 PCGS PR66DCAM 1937 Great Britain Crown - only DCAM graded PCGS MS67 1687 Austrian States Salzburg 3 Kreuzer
I also have a PCGS PL67-69!! 1907 Maundy Set with wild toning but I need to resubmit it to PCGS for some Trueviews.
OK, I have seemingly been "beaten at my own game" by someone younger than my oldest kid. I can deal with it. No, really, I can. That isn't depressing at all. Seriously, though, all I can say is "wow", laddie. WOW in capital letters. If you're here now, where will you be when you're my age? Is this how titans like @panzerman look in their formative years? Hmm. And already working at Atlas Numismatics. Wow again. At age 19, I was flipping hamburgers on the grill at McDonald's for $3.35 an hour. Yes indeed! And rather regret selling the other!
Well, thank you for the flattery! Seriously though, most of it I owe to just being in the right place at the right time (namely at my desk at Atlas). Wouldn't be able to do it without their never-ending supply of beautiful coins to cherrypick! But thanks again, it means a lot coming from someone with your experience.
For non-ancients, I feel that it has to be certified. For ancients, I'm ambivalent but I like NGC's photography and I honestly don't trust myself enough to keep raw coins without accidentally damaging them by dropping them all over the place.