Buffalo = Absolutely
Morgan = Absolutely NOT
I agree with Jason, the toning is very unusual for a 56 but the indicators all point to NT. If that coin is AT, it has achieved the pinnacle of...
NT on the Franklin
How did that not star, c'mon NGC
If the nickel isn't PL, then yes, it deserves a star.
That coin is beautiful and deserves a star. I wish that people would look past toning breaks that don't negatively affect the eye appeal of the...
Definitely a secondary toning but I don't know if I can call it artificial. I going with MA on this one.
Those are pretty but the toning on both looks very questionable. Still, how can you go wrong for $28.
Totally deserves a star, I love that coin.
Agreed, the rules for the star designation preclude any coin with toning approaching terminal. The entire obverse of that coin is terminally toned....
I'm not sure if it is AT but it is ugly as sin. I say NT/MA.
He is a member on the NGC forum also, but nobody over there could be considered "active" at this point.
Separate names with a comma.