johnmilton's Recent Activity

  1. johnmilton replied to the thread Please Grade This 1814 E/A Bust Half.

    I'd say VF-30 strictly on the obverse. The reverse is a weak strike issue, but it would make it a bear to sell unless it's an Overton...

    Sep 8, 2026 at 1:26 PM
  2. johnmilton attached a file to the thread GTG-1829 Half Dime.

    I voted MS-63, no CAC. Sorry, the fly specks would make it a pass for me. It could also be an MS-62 because of the specks. I would say...

    1833 Half Dime All.jpg 1834 Half Dime All.jpg Sep 8, 2026 at 1:22 PM
  3. johnmilton liked ldhair's post in the thread GTG-1829 Half Dime.

    I went with 63 and no CAC

    Sep 8, 2026 at 1:16 PM
  4. johnmilton attached a file to the thread Starting a short set of Indian cents.

    I built an set of Indian Cents when I was in high school and the early years of college. I had something like $1,200 in it and only got...

    1897 Cent All.jpg Sep 8, 2026 at 12:10 PM
  5. johnmilton liked Kasia's post in the thread GTG a Oversized 1882 John Matthews Soda Water Token!.

    It shouldn't be an advertising token but 1882 was the 50th anniversary and there was a 50 year commemorative medal struck by his heirs...

    Sep 8, 2026 at 11:59 AM
  6. johnmilton attached a file to the thread GTG a Oversized 1882 John Matthews Soda Water Token!.

    Here is an example of the John Mathews Civil War token. I only had one of these pieces for sale when I was dealer. Believe it or not, it...

    NY 630 AU-1a All.jpg Sep 8, 2026 at 11:35 AM
  7. johnmilton replied to the thread GTG a Oversized 1882 John Matthews Soda Water Token!.

    The sharpness is AU, but the significant rim issues knock it down the VF range for a new grade. I wrote an article about Mathews for...

    Sep 7, 2026 at 9:58 PM
  8. johnmilton liked fretboard's post in the thread GTG a Oversized 1882 John Matthews Soda Water Token!.

    Yeah it's an amazing piece and this John Matthews guy lived a famous life as the soda fountain king, here's another token and some pics...

    112610875c.jpg 112610875d.jpg Screenshot_140.png Screenshot_139.png Screenshot_141.png Sep 7, 2026 at 9:52 PM
  9. johnmilton replied to the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    It’s hard to write-off losses on coins unless you have established them as a regular income source. You can’t even offset coin loses...

    Sep 7, 2026 at 7:17 AM
  10. johnmilton replied to the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    When you are dealer, taking a loss is often the smart thing you do. You get your money out to buy something better. When I started my...

    Sep 6, 2026 at 8:14 PM
  11. johnmilton liked lordmarcovan's post in the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    This was an 1842-D half eagle in modest grade (PCGS VF30, CAC). Not a coin the big boys would fight over. But straight graded, with...

    Sep 6, 2026 at 8:10 PM
  12. johnmilton replied to the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    It's impossible to say if it was a good deal or a bad deal for you. All the Dahlonega coins I have held have done well. Damaged examples...

    Sep 6, 2026 at 11:57 AM
  13. johnmilton replied to the thread A/T Or Is There a Chance?.

    I think that the toning is okay on the Mercury dime. I can't see the "toning nuts" doing handsprings over it, however.

    Sep 6, 2026 at 11:39 AM
  14. johnmilton attached a file to the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    I hold items for so long that I seldem have losses, at least on paper. The biggest hit I have ever than was about $1 thousand. I would...

    1877 Twenty Cent me All.jpg Sep 6, 2026 at 11:36 AM
  15. johnmilton attached a file to the thread This flip didn't go well for this person. They paid $20,250 in 2025 and sold it for $11,000+ in 2026.

    This one is graded AU-55. It's the same type. The OP coin has a lot of scruffy mint surface left on it. This one has some general wear....

    1811$5O.JPG 1811$5R.JPG Sep 5, 2026 at 10:51 AM