The Toning Premium Thread Part 2

4,250

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

$4200

 

$4500

Ive been high lately

 

Coins with ultra high grades and high numismatic value don’t usually generate big toning premiums as the eye appeal is expected at that grade & price.

$3700

 

This one went for way under the guide price. $1974.38
Just another example of why you can never price a coin based on any one price guide.

 

Are you sure about that being the most recent selling price?

 

I looked at auction records for similar coins. Found 2 ngc 68 stars. Both cac One at $1880 one at $2100. Which looked like the same coin with a different cert number. A 68 no star at around $800 too. Guide way too high for this. As it’s not a series I know well

 

Ok. So I’ll put this one out there. Pcgs CoinFacts is $450. Greysheet at $300. Pcgs au 58. What did I pay. And for a bonus what did I sell it for. Needed money this spring and have major sellers remorse on this one

 

Bought: $365
Sold: $625

 

https://www.greatcollections.com/Coin/428237/1951-S-Washington-Quarter-NGC-MS-68-CAC-Toned

Same cert number

 

Yes that was from 9/3/17

 

I’ll say you sold it for $700

 

This is the same coin same grade different cert number. This was September 2015 I also think this coin was in a pcgs 67+ cac holder. I think we have a coin that’s been in the crackout cycle a few times

 

Didn’t look there looked on CoinFacts and HA

 

Which coin are we currently guessing? The Washington or Seated Liberty?

 

I have several higher end Morgan's, Walking Liberties that have very nice toning but this common date 1964 Washington Quarter is my favorite. Watched it tone over a 40 year period in a type set. Seems to change colors more than any I've owned.( blue,ruby,gold etc.)

 

Seated Liberty. We finished the Washington it sold for $1978.34

 

Gotcha, thanks.

Bought for $369.00
Sold for $468.00

 

Here are the rules to this thread,
Post #1
I was recently looking at a thread from @@Lehigh96 about toning premiums from the 2010-2011 time period.
https://www.cointalk.com/threads/the-toning-premium-thread.135678/ As toning continues to be both popular and controversial, I thought it would be interesting to see what posters have to say about the market for the past few years.

The rules are simple:
1. A toned coin with an approximate "guide price" will be posted.
2. Everyone has 24 hours to guess the premium/price paid (as well as their. thoughts of what the coin is worth).
3. Provide a reason for your guess (if it is just a wild guess, please say so).
4. The closest guess to the price that the coin sold for wins and gets to post the next coin.
*Note: please don't post another coin until the prior item has a declared winner.
5. If the winner does not want to post a coin or can't do so within 24 hours of being declared the winner, anyone is open to post their coin.

*Note#2: If the thread seems to lose interest, there may be room to alter the rules above.

ddddd, Jul 10, 2017 Report

 

Paid 500
Sold 750