I have a bunch of masonic pennies, and have seen similar ones on ebay for $10-$200. I would appreciate if anyone could give me more information.
First, welcome to the neighborhood @Jmointhecreev ! I'm guessing that the ones you see listed on FleaBay are sellers' asking prices. Personally, I wouldn't pay $10 for any of them. I got these for free from the retired Philly Mint employee who made the punches and dies for them. Chris
Well, there ARE rare designs and locations, and some bring BIG bucks. I'm always watching for them. If you want to confuse a seller, and fish for a discount, tell him, "I'd love to buy them, but I'm not a Mason..."
Would you mind posting examples of rare designs and those that have sold for big bucks? Sorry, but it's the skeptic in me. Chris
Found one in a roll of Half Dollars a while ago... https://www.cointalk.com/threads/masonic-token-found-in-half-dollar-roll.279242/