Guess the Grade (ICG --> PCGS)!

Hi all,

Recently robec was kind enough to let me piggyback his submission (for the second time!) to PCGS. One of the coins submitted was a 1932 H10 that was cracked out from an ICG slab (EDIT to add: It was formerly in an AU55 ICG slab). Anyone care to guess the grade that PCGS assigned it? Pictures below.





Have fun! Answer will be posted in a week or so.
-CB

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Something about that coin says cabinet wear. MS62?

 

They could either be on-point or one grade lower IMO. You'd really have to see the coin to tell though. It's a really nice looking half dime though.

 

I'm gonna say au-58 a nice looking coin with pretty retoning from an old dip

 

Beautiful! I went AU53.

 

MS-62.........

 

I was tempted by Au58, but voted questionable color. I think PCGS might object to the reverse color.

 

I think ICG got it right in the first place... Why would you re-submit it? Only if you were hoping for an upgrade, right? So I would say it's in an AU58 holder now.

 

Why wouldn't you a coin in a pcgs holder is a heck of a lot easier to sell then a coin in an icg holder people trust them more

 

ok I see the advantage from a dealer's perspective; as a collector I wouldn't do that

 

Wow it seems from the poll that people think that ICG is a tough grader. I never would've thought....

 

Yeah, but the fun will be in seeing what PCGS assigns it......

 

Me I graded the coin not the slab I said 58 was a tough call between 55 and 58 I went high due to the relative leiniency of the tpgs lately

 

Me? I graded the PCGS call.......

 

As a guy who has never had a coin graded & doesn't own a graded coin, how could this coin grade anything above an AU with the evident wear on the curls & eagle. Please do not take offense as I would LOVE to have this coin. I think it's magnificent! I just know that you guys know tons more than I do about the TPGs. This could be a very valuable learning experience for me.

 

I took the AU55, minimal wear on the obverse but much more wear on the reverse.

 

That's right, rev seems to have more wear, so finally I voted for Au55 as well.

 

I think ICG got it right...AU55.

 

I'll try AU 53, as well.

 

Not my series, but I went for 50. I could see it getting questionable color.