Which coin would you rather have

Would you rather have a 1868 NGC PF-65* Cameo Seated Half dollar, or a 1950 PCGS PF-66 Cameo Franklin Half dollar.

Charlie

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Personally the Franklin because that's what I collect mainly but don't let us be the deciding factor if it's a coin you plan to buy. Let that be your decesion.

 

I am not planing on buying either one soon, but I saw them both in the R & I Coins ad in Coin World and the Franklin was $4,800 more than the Seated Liberty.

Charlie

 

I'd say the Seated Half Dollar.

B12

 

The seated half...much more history.and I have a frankie (not cameo)

 

The Franklin.....I already have one but wouldn't mind another one.....

Why was the Franklin soo much....was it CAMEO or what....a PCGS PF66 Franklin would run under $700...I got mine for alittle over $400.

Speedy

 

I'd take the Franklin, sell it, buy the seated, and spend the rest on other coins.

 

I go for beauty over ugly, so SL half for me please.

 

Purely depends on how I would acquire the coin. If I had to buy it, steal it or it was given to me. In any case, I would just turn around and sell it for a profit hopefully and buy all the 55DD Lincolns I could find.

 

The Franklin fits my collect much better. If I started to collect Seat Liberty coins, well put it this way I can't afford to collect Seated Liberty Halves, at least now this decade.

In reality I can't afford a proof 1950 Franklin either, but it is always nice to think that I can...some day.

I'm just happy to have what I have.