Where would you grade these raw 1889 Carson City Morgans?

These two listings caught my eye. While the first one sold for higher, I was surprised since I though it would grade lower than the second one. Curious to hear more experienced eyes and collectors thoughts.

1889 CC#1
https://www.ebay.com/itm/325643890764?

1889 CC #2
https://www.ebay.com/itm/125921514798?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I don't understand why anyone would spend that much for a raw 1889-CC on ebay. To me both coins are counterfeits. Look at how wavy the bottoms of all the letters are on the reverses, and how misshapen they are.

 

Echo KBBPLL above.........

 

I don't collect Morgan's but I certainly wouldn't spend that much based on those pictures. Besides, big red flag that they are not in TPG holders. The prior comments cement the deal.

 

I saw the post and immediately saw issues. I grinned and moved on.

 

What was the question?

 

"Where"? The bathroom floor...

 

Reverse comparison of the two:



And to the VAM reverses:

 

Paid that much money and obviously knows very little about what was purchased. Jack even you can't help someone like this.

 

eBay is aware and removed the listings...