Aloha everyone, I have been searching everywhere online for a dealer who sells the rare Matte Proof Lincoln cents. I can't find them anywhere accept ebay, which I'm a little too nervous at buying them off there. I do hear people have been ripped off by taking a nice condition business strike cents and putting them in counterfeit PCGS slabs. I've heard of Eagle Eye Rare coins and they have some nice ones
Thepennylady has a couple anyway http://thepennylady.com/images/November_2009_Lincoln_Cents_for_Sale.pdf. Outside of that, try Heritage.
Thanks, I've been to the Penny Lady's website. She's always had nice looking pennies in here inventory.
"Angel Dee's" is the couple of Andy and Alynne Skrabalak. Along with Brian Wagner, Andy buys and sells some of the most wonderful MPLs known (as well as Proof Indian Head Cents and Matte Proof/Brilliant Buffalo Nickels). All high end stuff. His telephone number is 703-580-6969. Right now Andy has a "Liston" pedigree 1913 on is site that I've seen in-hand, and it's spectacular. Andy does not use photos, but his integrity is top shelf, and he has never steered me wrong. Brian Wagner helped me to build my first Matte Proof Lincoln set, and specializes in MPLs and Indian Head Cents. He deals with some monster coins as well.