I despise the 'bay but sometimes it's the easiest option. What would YOU pay for it (no CDN prices). Lol
I think the raw coin looks the best due to the reverse toning and might actually bring the most. Wide range depending on the color (anywhere from $30-$100 in an auction depending on who would be bidding). The PCI coin would get very low offers from most (especially dealers), but could go in the $40-$60 range on ebay. The NGC would likely be $45-$65 on ebay (depending if someone liked the toning). The two PCGS coins might get a rattler premium; I'd guess $75-$85 (although could be a little less or a bit more depending on who is looking).