What is a fair price to sell either of these IHC coins for?

I have two IHCs same year and mint. I am thinking about selling one here, I haven't decided which one I want. What were you charge for either here? I was thinking $2.75 take your pick.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Is the bottom one cleaned?

 

The coin on the left has rim damage at 9 o'clock, and I can't see the reverse of the second coin. I think you'd be lucky to get $1 for the first and $1.50 for the second (unfortunately, the later IHC are extremely easy to find in this condition.) Especially if you intend to charge shipping for them...

Just my two cents. But then, you never know who will buy things at what price...

 

The one in the left I got for $2.75 at auction including shipping. I guess the pictures were good and the terms "we are old time collectors" and "orginal coin" attracted bidders. I only paid a quarter more than the last bidder would pay. The one on the right, I actually bid on because nobody else did and got it for 99 cents free shipping. That is why I asked and Redbook price on both seems a little high for them. Now on the other hand, I see people bidding much higher for IHCs for some reason. Desirability always plays a big part a long with presentation. The one on the right was taken with crap on the camera lens. The seller claims their father owned a coin shop for 30 years and is now in college. I also noticed the grade was a little inflated. I believe that the right is better, telling by the curls and the diamonds present on the ribbon. Others on the forum stated that I did ok for the one on the left, that is why I thought $2.75 including shipping for either would be good. I kind of like them both so I may just keep them and hang on to them. I know that BadThad stated the one on the right is original. I bought the one on the right from the same seller I bought this one from for $2.09 with shipping. You are right though it is hard to tell who is going to buy what at what price. The one on the left above went for $2.75 and the higher grade one on the right went for 99 cents with shipping. They were both low price but the one on the left went for 2.75 times as much than the one on the right.

 

Here is the one coin with the back: