What Error is this?Looks very odd to me...Please Help??Thanks

Discussion in 'Error Coins' started by cosmoscoinguy, Feb 9, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    jjjjj_0001A1.jpg jjjjj_0001A2.jpg jjjjj_0001A3.jpg jjjjj_0001A4.jpg jjjjj_0001A5.jpg Looks Odd,,What do u guys think,,any worth to it?Thanks Tod
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. non_cents

    non_cents Well-Known Member

    Looks like a heavily damaged coin to me.
    Keep up the hunt!
     
  4. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    jjjjj_0001A6.jpg jjjjj_0001A7.jpg jjjjj_0001A8.jpg jjjjj 001_0001A9.jpg
    Here is a few more pics,,got this 1994 D,,roll picking along with a War nickel 1st roll I opened today...Tod jjjjj 001_0001A10.jpg
     
  5. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    The Edge is smooth and round,,not ruff as it would be if it were ran over.Tod
     
  6. mrweaseluv

    mrweaseluv Supporter! Supporter

    almost looks like a lamination error but I don't think that applies to nickels but it does look more like a planchette issue rather then post mint damage.
     
  7. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    I get OBW Rolls of 50's,6o's I see cracks around rims here and there but not like this Cir Coin I picked from a Safeway Roll,,,with Text up on a part of the coin where it is always flat,,this is raised up and cracked to the rim but yet the outer rim is smooth and rounded instead of the common flat smooth outer surface of the rim a nickel has.Tod
     
  8. micro

    micro Member

    I think you should hang on to this one and look further into finding out what has happened. Looks like "liberty" was applied on a cud.
     
  9. VDBforDave

    VDBforDave Lincoln Error Collector

    I would normally say PMD here, and I'm no expert, but on the reverse, where the word "States of America" on the bottom, seems as tho the rim is not folded down on the word in any way. Almost as if there is a flat cud like piece of coin partially covering the words. You can see a gap between the lettering and the covering piece of scrap.
    It's like a tri-hybrid of PMD, Lamination, and Cuds. hahaha I don't know what to conclude about this coin. Take what I said with a grain of salt, and not as an answer. :D
     
  10. mikediamond

    mikediamond Coin Collector

    The coin is heavily damaged. The edge is rounded and a thin apron of metal has been relocated from the edge and rim to the obverse periphery. You see this effect in "dryer coins" although this is not apparently a dryer coin. Regardless, it's post-strike damage.
     
  11. 16d

    16d Member

    Besides PMD, that was struck with a greatly deteriorated die. That's what I see.
     
  12. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    Thanks for all the post over the coin,,,Its not the rim over or folded over the letters the letters are all there some of which is on top of the crack and raised part of the coin,,someone must know,,guess it may be worth some cash being that most think it is a Error and can not put there finger on just what happen,,cool..Please anyone that know for sure or can figure it out please post?Thanks Tod
     
  13. ldhair

    ldhair Clean Supporter

    In my opinion, it's just damage created after it was minted.
     
  14. non_cents

    non_cents Well-Known Member

    It is more important to realize that the coin is simply damaged than to try and figure out exactly what damaged it. You will save time and energy just getting rid of is one and moving on.
    I can't see this coin bringing any cash because it is damaged.
    Keep up the hunt!
     
  15. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    Ok so far only a few may understand what they are looking at,,,16D seems to me to be the one who is right,,,for sure it is not damaged after the minting 100% not after the mint,,Thanks Tod
     
  16. non_cents

    non_cents Well-Known Member

    I'm sorry to break it to you, but your coin is simply damaged. I have seen similar effects before on coins. Even Mike Diamond (one of the foremost error experts in the nation) said it is damaged. You can believe that your coin is whatever error you like, but you are getting feedback from very knowledgable members saying you just have a damaged coin.
     
  17. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    Bummer nobody really knows yet..
     
  18. gunnovice09

    gunnovice09 Nothing

    You got your answer but you don't like it
     
  19. cosmoscoinguy

    cosmoscoinguy New Member

    Relax read all the posts, nobody has said for sure one way or the other that matters,
     
  20. gunnovice09

    gunnovice09 Nothing

    I'm relaxed I'm just saying some of the experts on here said its pmd but to don't like the answer so you want another.
     
  21. VDBforDave

    VDBforDave Lincoln Error Collector

    I'm a bit lost myself now. What type of answer are you looking for? You said the answer you thought was closet was the die deterioration, and I even know myself as a new collector; Die Deterioration is NOT sought after, or anything valuable. Non cents is correct, this coin is very damaged. If this coin was a high grade, fresh and not all dinked up, and still had a similar rim error, then maybe you may have something.
    Just for that 1 small chance, I also checked The Cud Book I have by Sam Thurman and Arnold Margolis(Reputable is their middle name), and nothing was shown like your coin.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page