Two 1937-S Buffs. Which one do ya like the best?

I have a couple of 37-S Buffs and I was wondering which one ya like the best. Help me out as I can not decide...Thanks

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

You can't decide what? Which one to send me?
They're both terrible. I will pm you my address.
But really, I prefer the first one.

 

I wouldn't kick either of them out of the house but, I have to also say the first one.
Just beautiful!!

 

Nickels are the only coin that I like toning on. Those are both very good looking.
It's like asking which of my children is my favorite. Both of your nickels are great.

 

The top one has been graded 66 by NGC. The bottom one is in a pcgs rattler graded 65....

 

Number 1 is far nicer on the eye. I would go with that one

 

The Ngc has a better strike and a bit more eye appeal

 

I like the toning of the first one better.

 

Another vote for the first. Its awesome!

 

I'm liking the gold toning on the second coin.

 

First one!

 

I would have to say that the second one has a better strike (more hair on the Bison's shoulder and a more sharply defined horn). The toning is better on the first one though IMO. Since I always go with eye appeal, from these pictures, I'd take the first one.

 

Definitely the first one. Somewhat lesser strike, but blue is my favorite toning color.

 

Although I love the rainbow toning on the first one, the second one is definitely my favorite

 

I'm a fan of the 2nd, but both are lovely.

Thanks for sharing, coin dexter!

-Brian

 

Can't decide. They are both beautiful.

 

They are both nice, but I prefer the more consistent color of coin #2. It also (at least from the photos) appears more lustrous.

 

I'm an idiot but to me they look like the same coin.

Ruben

 

#2

 

I really like the eye appeal of #1, more interesting colors and I'm not a huge fan of the gold hue of #2. You're call though and I bet you'll be happy with either