two 1831 quarters

Could I please have some help grading and valuing these coins?
Coin 1:
Front:

Back:

Coin 2:
Front:

Back:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

bigger pictures?

 

Can't see a lot of detail, and the link to the gallery doesn't work on my computer.

From the small pics, I'd say EF or so.

 

Coin one:


Coin two:

 

coin 1, I'll say F-12.
coin 2, VF-20, but the rim dings would net it at F, I think.
used ANA 6th ed. for grading.

 

looks like the same pictures to me, but made larger and no more detail.

Ruben

 

I think coin 1 is F12 maybe F15. The second coin is VF25, but like mentioned with the rim dings I would also net it to F. To me the first coin is the nicer of the two.

 

Is coin 2 cleaned? You usually see light areas on these where wear is like coin 1.

 

I'd say F on both. Nice coins.
Guy~

 

Personally, I have some concerns about whether they're genuine, particularly the second one. The denticles don't look right.

If they are genuine :

#1 - F15 details, no luster due to an old cleaning, discolored reverse fields, net G4

#2 - VF20 details, no luster due to an old cleaning, bumps and bangs, net G6, maybe VG8. It doesn't look genuine to me.

Similar 1831s have sold for about $50 on Heritage.

 

Agreed. Even though the eagle has less detail on #1, it's overall much better than #2.

 

Here are some additional coins, could I get your thoughts on them?
1835:


1877 - This coin was done a great disservice by the scanner in realty all the letters of “liberty” on the shield are clearly legible as are the letters of “in god we trust” on the banner on the back, and the date for that matter


An 1883-O Morgan:


1881-O


1884-O - the scratches are nowhere near as distracting in real life, and the back is much more lustrous, almost proof like




To be quite honest the scanner did a terrible job with this lot of coins and the last two.

 

And another that pushed the images over 10:
1883-O

 

I really like that 1884 O morgan.
Guy~

 

Well for the 1835 I would go with F-12 and maybe VG10 for the seated 1877. The morgans are why you need a camera and not a scanner. I can't really see enough on the morgans to hazard a guess.