Question re Morgans - should I get a few graded and which service is better

Hi everyone, new to this forum. Been collecting Morgans and Peace for the last 2 years and picked up a 1900-o. Studied up on the counterfeits http://www.coinresource.com/news/news2005/pcgs_declares_counterfeits.htm and this coin passed muster. At least from my inspection. It is uncirculated as far as I can tell but who knows if it's ever been cleaned - right. Should I get it graded? I paid $42 at an estate auction just for S&G's and I think they didn't know what to value it at. So I took a gamble and it is beautiful.I also picked up an uncirculated 1880 that is stunning and was thinking of getting it slabbed as well. I know the 1900-o with a high grade is worth some serious coin but just wanted to get feedback from others as to NGC or PCGS and is it worth it. Anyone with experience doing this I would appreciate your feedback. Thanks in advance

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Well, I personally would prefer NGC, but the boards are pretty much split, they both are pretty much the same thing...IMO
I own coins from both companies and have never had a problem with either.... I just think NGCs slabs are more...stylish?
Could you possibly post a picture of the coin??

 

Yes, I will tonight when I get the kiddies to bed. Thanks for the reply.

 

Arg...it won't let me do it from my iPad. I'll try again on the laptop tomorrow

 

Actually if genuine either PCGS or NGC would be a good choice. I think on morgans they are about equal.