Is it worth the extra bucks to get a proof coin rather than a uncirculated coin? I would like you advice on this, even if it is just your opinion. The two coins are: http://mintissue.ramint.gov.au/mintissue/product.asp?code=800726 (Proof) http://mintissue.ramint.gov.au/mintissue/product.asp?code=800721 (Unc) Thanks in advance! :smile (I apologize if this is the wrong forum to place this thread in, I'm still quite new here)
All depends on whether you prefer Proof or Unc. It's not really a "worth" question - it's a preference question. And that depends on the individual.
Apparently your definition of "straight" is "simplistic and absolute." Frankly, I consider GDJMSP's response to be as "straight" as possible. I collect primarily circulated coins because I enjoy the sense of history that they convey when I think about where they have been, and what they may have been used for. That's the "right" way for me to collect, because that's what I enjoy. But if I were to pontificate that "collecting circulated examples is the only proper way to collect coins" I would be quite properly laughed off the forum. The folks in the PCGS/NGC registry set crowd compete to see what percentage of their collection can be assembled with coins that have never been anyplace but in a collector's hands. If one of them were to pontificate that "collecting high grade MS coins is the only proper way to collect coins" I would have to suggest that they pound salt. Others limit their collections to non-circulating proof coins, and still others gather bullion. Neither of those is the "only proper" to collect either. Another type of question for which the only legitimate answer is "it depends on what you enjoy" is "Should I collect US coins, world coins from one country or a related group of countries, date/mintmark series, type sets, etc., etc." Again, I enjoy modern Japanese coinage, including the coinage of other countries while dominated by Japan. Speedy is a US collector. Aidan collects British Commonwealth coins. Other people have lots of other collecting styles, and each one is the "proper" method for that person. As Doug so accurately and eloquently said Since I don't collect bullion, I don't collect Australian (except as part of a one per country collection), and I don't generally collect coins that haven't actually circulated, for me the answer to the question that started this thread is "neither one is worth the price to me. That's not good advice to give Numismaticist because he has decided that he wants the coin, but just isn't sure which version is appropriate for him. Instead of complaining about the imprecision of other people's truthful and accurate responses - even though they aren't the answer you would give - why don't you respond directly to Numismaticist's request for your opinion as a fellow forum member? BTW - to CoinTalk Numismaticist.
Both the kangaroo coins are very nice and will look good in any collection... one is proof, the other is frosted unc. But if u have to decide on one, then in my opinion, go for the proof version. Mintage for proof is a mere 12.5k compared to the unc version, unlimited mintage... down the road that's gonna make some difference if the series gets more popular or if u decide to make money from it later, although u probably won't wanna sell the coin anyway, so it will end up benefiting ur kids. If u ask me whether to collect proof or unc coins, then I have to agree with GDJMSP. It's all abt ur preference, not worth... if u like shiny mirrorred surfaces then go ahead and buy the proofs... buy what you like and let fate decide the rest.
If you can afford the proof then go with it All my Kook's are uncirculated but I still think they look lovely LOL and honestly it is a matter of preference De Orc
The proofs are much more appealing to the eye or my eye if you will. I prefer proof because of their "finish". I have a KooK proof and it is one of or the most beautiful coin I have, because of the "finish" and the art. Get them both!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If you can afford it.
Thanks a ton everyone, I think I'll just buy the unc coin since it's about half the price, and I have a very limited budget at the moment. I might decide to save up and also get the proof, or a proof version of a different coin.
