I think he means this one Rick..... https://www.cointalk.com/threads/any-thoughts-guys-and-gals.249550/#post-1958593
Thank you G18, as a "coin" collector, low mintage, and condition mean everything, suddenly I am told nothing is real, ("and nothing to get hung about")for the Beatles fans, anyway, I am told that it's all melt, so far no one has disagreed with that, what's up ...............
The Libertad set is certainly not just melt. The 5 piece proof set from either 1993 or 1994 is worth upwards of $200. That's five times their melt value.
Generally for collectors, condition is more important than mintage. It has to do with supply and demand. I have military trade tokens that have mintages of 5,000 with an unknown amount surviving, that can be bought for ten dollars or less. A coin minted from a precious metal like gold or silver will at least retain their melt value but may lose or develop a collector value. Look at Morgan dollars. Even cull examples are still worth something.
