It pays to review your collection now and then. I knew I had this coin, but I had never imaged it. From one of my incomplete sets; hard to find these in the XF/AU range.
He said he knew he had it, probably in his junk box. My junk box is full of stuff like this, often given as gifts to kids to promote the hobby.
Turns out I HAD imaged this coin but had mis-named it. The coin itself was where it was supposed to be. I just didn't know it because of the naming error.