One Real, One Fake & GTG

Sent these two off to PCGS, and just got the grades today. These are the pics before submission. One came back real and I was surprised with the grade, and one came back counterfeit. Can you guess which is which, and guess the grade of the real one.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Oh boy. I think the $10 is fake.

 

Yikes... if you posted a $2 1/2 I could tell ya.. but I do not know these as well. One of them is a pretty darn good fake though. I'm going with the $10 as fake as well. I will say MS61 on the $3.

 

This would be my guess, too, but I'm not a gold person. To me, the date on the $10 doesn't look right.

Chris

 

Normally I would always guess the $3. They are simply counterfeited a lot more than other gold. However, I have to agree my eye is telling me something is wonky on the $10. If I have to say the $10 is fake, then I cannot see higher than AU for the $3.

 

I guessed MS on the grade since he was surprised by it. So it either did that, or XF.

 

IMO, The $10 Ind. is no good the rim looks weird. The $3 my guess is AU55

 

My guess is the $10 is fake as well. Couldn't tell you why, though.
And I think the $3 looks AU-53.

 

I'll go with the Indian as well. The mint mark looks off to me. I'll go with AU50 on the $3.

 

$10 is fake and the $3 got a 50.

 

10 is fake MM looks NG and rim too AU 50 on the three dollar piece....

 

yup 10 fake, 3 is a au low 50s

 

I agree with your observation about the "boogered" rim on the $10. I would grade the $3 at AU50, I actually think that it lies between XF45 and AU50.

 

$10 is Fakey McFakerson. I'll say 45 on the $3.

 

I am going to LOL if the $3 is the fake one

 

Me too! As much as I want to say the $3 is fake just for the fun of it, I'll say $10 is fake and $3 is MS63.

 

Everything is said, the Indian is fake and the three dollar piece is unc.....maybe a 62..

 

Everyone keeps saying the Indian is fake..... aren't they both Indians?