Odd 1963 Franklin -- clip, planchet defect, something else?

I bought a small lot of silver halves, and in the seller's photos this one looked like it had been rim-dented or otherwise abused; I bid accordingly. But when I got it in hand, this is what I found:



It has clearly circulated a good bit, and looks like it got a small rim ding just below 3:00 on the obverse. But I see a pretty clear Blakesley effect, especially at the L of Liberty. Given the extent of the weakness around TRUST and AMERICA, I wondered if there might be some sort of void inside the planchet -- but now I'm wondering if that's just normal for a small ragged clip, as the metal flows toward the collar instead of into the devices.

Weight is 12.04g, about .30-.35g less than other specimens with comparable wear.

Anyone else seen something similar?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Look! Up in the sky! It's a bird! It's a plane! No, it's @paddyman98 !

Chris

 

Lol ..................

 

Definitely CF, mail it to me. ;-)

Thank you.

 

Pretty interesting. The fissure in the planchet makes me think, of a cutting error, the clip looks straight to me.

 

Cue, for anybody to have nerve to name that!

 

I wish I had the equipment to non-destructively test how far the fissure extends into the coin, but I sure don't. I'd be willing to risk contact ultrasound imaging on a coin that's already this worn, but I don't know anything about machines that would work at this scale (essentially ultrasound microscopy).

 

If it was a cutting error the fissure was made by the tool, and it isn't a void in the planchet.

 

As I stare more closely at the edge-on image, I wonder whether there's a "fissure" at all, or whether it's just an artifact of the way metal flowed into the void between the planchet and the collar.

 

That could be, cool find, I hope Fred or Mike will help with some of their knowledge

 

I'm still leaning towards a planchet defect on the edge because I think the the pressure during striking would not be enough to fill some of the reeding and still leave the fissure behind it. I also think that a void extending slightly into the coin would explain very weak letters in TRUST.

However, your idea of a ragged clip with some partial filling of the rim is certainly a reasonable explanation worth considering

 

it's a ragged end or end of strip clip.

 

Good enough for me. Thanks!

 

Hahahaha

 

It looks to me like a defect or a clipped for sure. Exhibits blankelsy effect
Disc clip maybe?