New acquisition for my type set -- let's all grade it!

I've wanted to get a Seated Liberty Silver Dollar for my post-1800 US type set and I finally found a decent, affordable specimen:




It's hard to tell from the scan, but Liberty is complete and the scroll edges appear to be raised. There's just a hint of luster left.

I'm thinking VF-35/EF-40 on the grade.

Thoughts?

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I'd give the reverse an XF, as the wear seems really light. The obverse shows the wear more, and looks VF... so you get a VF. I like it though! A nice original coin! I like them with lots of that 'patina' (that sounds nicer than crud, doesn't it?). It could go XF with some graders, who knows?

 

Gorgeous original coin. I grade it XF 40.

 

Beautiful!!! I say VF as well.

 

From the pic I see that Liberty is not full but everything else has great detail!So maybe VF-30. B12

 

nice original. I say VF-35

 

PG-13 due to the nudity

 

Another SGS MS70

 

Nice coin, but it's such an ugly dark color. You should throw it in the pocket of your jeans and run it through the washer.

 

I'll say XF-45

Bone

 

If you do any such thing to such an original nicely toned coin, I will hunt you down and put you in a jeans pocket and put you in the washer. ...Mike