Need Help with authentication of coins

Hello,
We have an estate sale company and are responsible for pricing and evaluating these for a family. We took these to a couple of places locally to help authenticate, with various opinions. We do not want to put these in a sale if they are fake priced as real.
We are not looking for values, just an honest opinion of if they are real or not, what to look for etc.
We have lots of knowledge in fine jewelry and watches and other antiques/collectibles, but we do not have much knowledge of these. We see the potential value we want to be sure.
Thank you for any help you may be able to provide.

I know sometimes it helps to know a little history of items. We only know that our client is an elderly gentleman. He said that he acquired the coins 14 yrs ago.
When his father died he found them in the back of his fathers desk, he put them in a suitcase with some other items, and he has had them in that suitcase ever since he brought them home.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

Stand firm in your price they look legit.

 

You will be leaving an extremely large sum of money on the table - some of these might have value reaching five digits - if they are not authenticated and graded by a respectable third-party grader. Most of them are types which a prudent collector simply would not purchase outside a slab. I do not mean to seem cryptic, but a forum like this does not lend itself to the small book I'd need to write in order to cover each coin in the detail it deserves.

Whatever you read here, and there will likely be some knowledgeable folks responding, do_not offer these coins in raw ungraded form.

 

The 1814 dime shown in the picture is a fake. It does not match any of the 5 known die varieties. The reverse purports to be JR-5 (Statesofamerica) variety, but JR-5 looks nothing like that. Also, the obverse and reverse lettering and overall style is not congruent with that of authentic coins.

I am not an expert on Capped Bust halves, but the date style of the 1807 is unlike any that I have seen. It looks very strange. I have strong doubts about that coin.

 

The 1814 dime is fake, the 1807 half next to it is fake, the 1798 dollars are fakes I would say the 1797 half dollars is fake and I would say several others are fake as well. With that many readily identifiable fakes in the group I would consider them all suspect without in hand authentication, and not just from mediocre images.

 

The coins need to be pulled from the sale. That's a shame. If real they would need to be sent to a major coin auction to receive the true value of the collection. Hope you have someone in your area that can check each coin. Maybe there is something in the group that's real.

 

Nope, not even close.

As stated, several of these coins are suspicious. If you have a coin dealer local to you, I would recommend taking them to the dealer and asking for an in-hand opinion. It is possible that some of them are genuine.

However, there are at least 2 coins in that pile that could be $30k$-$75k (each).... which means you really want to be sure. It also, unfortunately, means there's a good chance they're fake.

 

I realize that I said something I shouldn't have. I don't have the experience that others here have.

 

There is something that is bothering me about the coins. From a distance they look like pretty good fakes, but I close up there maybe some signs that they are fake. All of them have this mushy, off look, and I can't quiet put my finger on it. I think most of them, if not all, are fake.

 

EVERYONE has been very helpful. We think we may have the coins looked at further. Will weighing them help in comparing them to alike coins? Thank you

 

If the weight is incorrect, they are definitely fake.

If the weight is correct, that doesn't mean they are good - counterfeiters quite often use the correct weight and metal, to fool people.

 

Well worth the sub.Send them in and keep us posted.
Good luck.

 

I have a Dime just like your 1814 and sent it in to be graded! Looks very similar to yours

 

The 1795, and both 1798 dollars are fakes. I'd say the 1794 and 1797 1/2 dollars are most likely fake. The 1814 dime is fake. I suspect the 1807 half-dollar next to it of being fake. The other half dollars I am less sure about, but I would consider them guilty by association. If ANY of these coins have a reeded edge (except for the dime) they are fake. Many of the fakes from the time when these were made are also magnetic, not all of them, but many of them. So that would be another easy test.

 

I concur on the experts opinions. None of the coins pass muster.