My first impression is 63, but if the luster really booms, I could see 64. Since photos don't usually show luster very well, I tend to default towards contact marks.
I’m probably wrong, but my gut was 58. I felt I saw a difference in color and luster on the eagle chest and leg. It also looks like slight rub on the hand, breast, chest, and cheek. Regardless at this price, I would like CAC to be involved.
David has always been fair to me as well. Very knowledgeable and a good eye. I’ve sold him some nice stuff