Yes, luster grazes are pain. I see you solved that problem by having a circulated coin graded.:devil:
Wow, someone has his panties in a bunch! It's a common coin, I've pulled better from pocket change. At least Lehigh's is nice.
I should hope Paul's (lehigh) is nice. It's a Satin Finish example from a mint set. I've actually almost never seen a Satin Finish coin graded that low at a mere MS67.
I would love to have a Canadian coin in a PCGS sample slab, but the only ones I have ever seen, the seller (eBay) would not ship to Canada...
Ummm i'm no pro here, but if it was a satin finish it would have graded like an SP67, not an MS67, or it would be listed as a satin finish coin. IMHO it clearly looks like a high grade circulation strike and going by my gut and having seen many of Lehigh's postings/pictures before i'm sure it is one of the best out there, scar or not... I went ahead and looked up an MS67 2005 D on the PCGS pop report and actually there are 256 MS66's out there but "ZERO" MS67's... Not exactly pocket change... To the OP: Cool sample slab, i'm sure your son will enjoy it
What does the SMS stand for then in the grade? Its a mint set from 2005 the first year they released the satin finished coins in mint sets.