Mindless Gold Question

Discussion in 'US Coins Forum' started by glaciermi, Aug 18, 2006.

  1. glaciermi

    glaciermi Senior Member

    To the powers that be:

    The $10 gold AmericanGoldEagle is: .866 in diameter
    sells for $215 (Proof) .25 gold troz oz.
    0.2727 troy oz. of gold.
    The $ 5 gold AmericanGoldEagle is: .65 in diameter
    sells for $105 (Proof) .10 gold troz oz.
    0.1091 troy oz. of gold.
    The $ 5 San Franciso Commemorative: .85 in diameter
    sells for $230 (Proof) 8.359 grams
    90% gold, 10% alloy

    So i'm not a gold person, but how do these three coins relate.. despite the difference in wording, why isn't the 2006 $5 Gold Proof San Francisco Mint Commemorative.. not a $10 Gold Proof in denomination it sounds much closer to that value? or is this merely the call of Congress.. and having something to do with Coin vs. Bullion?
     
  2. Avatar

    Guest User Guest



    to hide this ad.
  3. tcore

    tcore Coin Collector

    I was thinking the exact same thing myself. I don't know why they make the commems' denomination $5 when they're nearly the same weight as the 1/4 oz eagle. As a matter of fact, I don't know why on Earth they don't make them the exact same purity, weight and denomination as the 1/4 oz Eagle. Why not make it 22K instead of 21.6K...makes no sense to me. :rolling:
     
  4. Krasnaya Vityaz

    Krasnaya Vityaz Always Right

    Commemorative is same dimensions, specifications of old $5 coin.
     
  5. Victor

    Victor Coin Collector

    The denomination really doesn't matter that much. The price of Gold goes up and down like a roller coaster.
     
  6. walterallen

    walterallen Coin Collector

    I think you nailed this one.
     
  7. tcore

    tcore Coin Collector

    Yes, but that's not really my point. The somewhat strange thing is that you have the U.S. Mint producing two gold coins at the same time that are nearly similar in many respects (close in weight <~1/4 oz>, gold content <.90 vs..9167>, etc.), but are just off slighty and they don't have the same denomination. Also, as we all know, the denomination on today's gold coins makes no difference whatsoever. There's no real problem with any of this. It's just kind of weird. Even though the denomination doesn't matter, one would logically think that two gold coins from the same time period that basically have the same dimensions would have the same denomination.
     
  8. GDJMSP

    GDJMSP Numismatist Moderator

    That's the problem - you're trying to use logic when talking about the mint :rolleyes:
     
Draft saved Draft deleted

Share This Page