Lincoln, Grade opinions.

here we go, one 1958 D NGC graded, and the 36 is raw
grade away
.. oo I like these pics

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

#1- MS-64
#2-MS-62

stainless

 

I will guess that the 36 is 63 red. I think I should pass on the 58-D except to ask stainless what he sees wrong with it that he only gives it a 62

 

I agree with you skipping the 58.
only a 63 on the 36?

 

Nice Coins.

36p-ms64
58d-ms66

Regards,
S

 

Both MS 65

 

Those spots do not help. but that scratch on the cheek drops it that low IMHO.

 

I'll also pass on the 58D due to inside info, but I'll go 64 on the 1936 because the luster screams

 

The 36 I'll say an easy MS-65, and the 58-D I'll say the same. Very nice coins the both of them! :thumb:

Phoeinx

 

36 I will say 65 and 64 on the 58-D. On the 58-D I did not like the spotting or the ding on the wheat lines. Just my opinion and I am certainly no expert on wheaties.

 

sorry forgot to say grades after it was all done. the 58D is NGC MS 66 RD
and the 36 Is raw and a 65 IMO

 

spots and very light scratches


stainless

 

the scratches are on the slab

 

my bad....then assuming all scratches are on the slab...I'd say MS-64..

stainless