I've collected coins for about 35 years but I've never really looked for specific coins. I've bought from a few dealers, but always something that caught my eye, or that was listed on a web site or in a catalog. I live in the boonies now and haven't found any local dealers or coin shows in the area. I am working on a Capital Plastics 20th Century type set and have specific needs for the set. I am looking for basically a matched set of 1913 Buffalos (type I and II). I want the 2 coins to look as close as possible to each other in condition (AU-58 or so) and original color (minimal to no toning). It's just me but I think having both coins the same year and look the same will add to the eye-appeal of the set. I'll be looking to do the same with the 1909 Indian, Lincoln, and Lincoln V.D.B.. This looks like a long lead-in to the actual question of how do I go about locating these nickels? Should I email a bunch of dealers with this request, will I have to travel to dealers or coin shows, or are there other options? What is the correct way to make what I guess would be a want list request? Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Look for online dealers and try ebay...and coin Auction Co.'s.... Some places will take a want list but I find that more harm that its worth....I may want a 1955 PF66 Franklin one week and have all of the money on hand but my dealer may find it 3-4 weeks after that and I might not have all of the $$ at once...so I find it better just to take it as it comes and not worry about giving a want list out. Speedy
Not an expert here, but by the description of your requirements what you are trying to do is like matching two stones, ie gems such as diamonds, rubies, saphires, etc. You can purchase 10 stones with the exact same specs (weight, diameter, clarity, etc.) and end up with 10 different stones. Matching the color and fire of each stone can only really be done hands on. I'd say only buy the coin you can inspect in hand and possibly bring your coin (in an airtight) for comparison. In the long run, I'd think you'll be happier. I also agree that it will make for more eye appeal with your sets
Go to a major or semi-major coin show, where you can see the wares of multiple dealers, and compare them.
