How do you folks feel about this offering ?

Anyone have the current Dealer-Dealer info for this one . He is shooting for $1,800.00

What say you ? I say nooooooooo .http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=260663886732&ssPageName=STRK:MEWAX:IT

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

He is in competition with another MS64 PCGS listed for $460. Maybe after that one sells, he is the only game in town, but against the other coin, it's too highly priced. IMHO

gary

 

Well, you could "buy it now" for $1750.......

 

and ya' get $20 in eBay Bucks for that too!!! $1,730...

 

485/535 But that does not include the premium for a full head

 

It is a beautiful coin, no doubt about it. But he is asking waaaay too much.
RedBook in MS-63 is only $475. Coin Prices Magazine, another retail price catalog, lists MS-65 for that coin as 1200.
Don't have access to the current GreySheet, but I'll guesstimate that coin's bid/ask is somewhere betw $400-500.

 

I don't think the guy is that far off. Heritage sold one just like it for $1840 back in April and it don't look as nice as this one to me. PCGS FH bring big bucks over what Red Book shows.

 

Well, still available at $1750 childrens....

 

I was wondering why it was already bid up to $1000. The full head must really be worth a premium. Either that or he's got a shill out there working for him.

 

485-535 according to greysheet, maybe add 10 for the plastic, and 20 for the FH, but for a 1917 fh is more typical than not.

 

...and ya' get $20 in eBay Bucks for that too!!! $1,730...

​

 

I'm gonna have to pass.

 

Thanks. This is what I was searching for , but this sounds high for a 64FH dealer to dealer as well or is that the blue sheet your giving me ?

 

They typically do not trade for this money. Don't get me wrong , this is a real nice 64FH and it might even bump . I dare say, I am fairly certain this won't sell at his reserve price.

 

That is a nice coin and $1k is not unreasonable, IMO. $1.7k is pushing it -- unless it's an upgrade candidate, which it does not appear to be from the photo. I would pay no more than $1.25k for that coin, and frankly there's more value in a P mint if you're a type collector.

It appears to be a very nice coin.

 

Here is the sales history at Heritage:

http://coins.ha.com/common/search_r...=mode+matchall&y=0&N=51+790+231+367&Nty=1&x=0

 

Yes that is current greysheet

 

The PCGS price guide adds $1050 for the FH on this coin. Not saying the guide is correct but it's probably close.
Those two little letters mean a lot to folks that collect these. It will be interesting to see if it sells.

 

$1,250 is pushing the envelope too . The best attribute this coin has to offer is the " Toning " . They more commonly are offered in Blast White . The current asking price is well above full retail . And, you are correct about the P mint issue . I'm sorta rooting for the bidders to hold their ground on this one . Interesting to watch how this plays out. Don't forget the added Sales Tax when you buy!

 

That adds an $147 to the buy it now price. Excellent point to keep in mind