Help with Grading 2004 P Wisconsin Quarter for Son's Birthyear Set

Hello, posted a thread in the error section but not getting any traffic in there on helping with grades.

I am working on 2004 Birthyear set for my son - proofs in PF70 and business strikes in MS67 or better. The only coin I cannot find is the Wisconsin P in MS67. So, I bought a roll of bank rolled in hopes of picking out a few of the best and submitting to NGC.

Most of the roll had a mint struck thru debris error on the reverse. Two of the coins look pretty good. Do you think either of them will grade atleast MS67? Your help is appreciated:

Coin 1: (has a mark, like a die crack but I don't think it is on the left side of the obverse)




Coin 2:

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

I am not sure either will make 67, but I am no expert on these coins. The first appears to have to many hits in the fields and the second has lots of rim chatter. So wait for someone who knows more about these than me.

 

I don't think they coud make 67 maybe 62

 

Anyone else? I thought both were close, but maybe I am off.

 

Is it me or does the first one look like a magical extra leaf error? Just very faint, but I think it is.