Guess tthe Grade #24

1922- NGC slabbed

This round should give some interesting results.

NOTE: If you don't vote in the poll, your vote will not be counted

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

See the other poll at http://www.cointalk.com/t118469/

 

I'll say.....this is a toughie. I bumped my grade just a little.

 

8

 

Ag3. Tc

 

Ag 3, but I want to say fair 2......

 

Only because you're treating it like a typical Lincoln instead of an over graded key. To make G4, it should have worn, but full legends. AG 80%, Fr 40% P or B <40%. But they never listen to me.

 

brutal....

 

I say G6, don't know how to completely grade these.
Regular grading standards go out the door for any key coin.

 

I thought a G4 coin has to have complete rims? Then again, you guys are always talking about how PCGS grades key coins easier :goofer:

 

4...but he mentioned it's in a NGC holder, stealer

 

Muhahahahaha.....NICE! You should have added some AG and FR grades to the poll for the folks that don't know Lincolns.

I gave it a 6 but it might be an 8. Is that a DP1 or 4? I have a DP1 that's graded by ANACS at VG-10. EVERYONE guesses that coins grade wrong. LOL

 

The rotation should give it away. It is #3.

 

my guess is 4

 

Guessing its a 4 as well.

 

4 but could be 3

 

Ag3.

 

I guess I've been grading circulated Lincolns wrong for 45 years.

 

Since the power company screwed my schedule up yesterday, I will be ending these tomorrow. See also http://www.cointalk.com/t118469/.

 

Well, I warned you. You did not do well on either coin. This 1922- is a rough coin to grade and to photograph. Yes, it is a VG coin. It is not the best strike even for one of the worst struck coin out there.