Guess the grades.. ANACS vs PCGS 1914 $2 1/2 Indians

I have 2 1914 $2 1/2 Indians, both have straight grades (not cleaned, etc). What do you think they are, and what do you think pcgs and anacs graded them? I apologize for the terrible pictures. I have never been able to take pictures in holders without the glare. That is what you see in some of the pictures. ANACS is the white holder.

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

PCGS 55
ANACS 63

 

Pcgs 58 anacs 62

 

PCGS 40
ANACS 45

 

Holy lowball, batman. Interesting compared to the other guesses so far.

 

XF 45
MS 63

 

Pcgs 61
Anacs 58

 

Interesting you think the pcgs is higher grade.

 

We have had guess ranging from 40-61 on the pcgs, and 45-63 on the ANACS so far.

 

Pcgs 53
Anacs 58

 

50
58

 

I see both as 45-50.

 

50
55

 

PCGS 55
ANACS 61

 

PCGS AU50/53
ANACS AU55/58

 

Here are the grades. I honestly feel the ANACS coin is far superior to the PCGS. I would grade the PCGS around 53-55, and ANACS at the 60-61 grade, based on other graded Indians I have.

 

But I was the closest or second for the ANACS - at least according to ANACS.

 

haha, you were! But I strongly disagree with the grade

 

I'm not surprised at all. Then again, I'm biased since I work for ANACS...