Guess the grade... PCGS Graded

Hi Group, Missed you guys this week. Had to get a bunch of stuff done and didn't take the time to post or even read.
I got this back last week expecting a 66RD, what do you think? Yes I see the bag mark on the shoulder, but...

 

Log in or Sign up to hide this ad.

The shoulder mark and the two in the hair might have bumped it down. My guess, based on your disappointment, is that it received a 64. I would have thought it would have graded closer to a MS65.

 

I think it is remarkably nick free, but I am not seeing any luster. 65 if it actually has some luster. 64 or genuine if it really is that flat.

 

Good to great luster...

 

Not showing quite the luster for a 66. IHO.

 

Trick question, I think it came back Ms-66 RD

 

I don't think those "dings" on the shoulder and hair are dings. I believe they were left when the planchet was flattened.

I'll say 66+RD.

 

65.

 

'64........

 

65

 

I'm low ball and say since you posted this as a disappointment i would say ms64!!

 

BTW nice looking cent.

 

Well, Guys... I was disappointed, but most of you were headed in the right direction. I do believe the coin is a 66 BUT!!!

 

It has very good wagon wheel luster, just bounced the flash to give more detail